Do You Know It All?

Last week’s Technology That Fits newsletter (sign up here) stimulated some interesting discussions. I showed the following graphic:

Doomed Projects

Everybody agreed that projects that choose good tools for good reasons are good, and projects that choose bad tools for bad reasons are bad. But some disagreed on Learning and Lucky categories above.

I call projects that choose good tools for bad reasons “lucky”. They are CMMI level 1 – sometimes they succeed, sometimes they fail, and they never get any wiser. I’m not recommending you accept that as a satisfactory state of affairs, but for an individual project, being lucky is enough to pull off a success.

Projects that seem to have good process but make tool choices you disagree on are “Learning” projects. Some people will walk out or loudly complain if their favorite tool is not used. I find that to be a narrow-minded approach. If clever people have chosen a different approach from you, it means you have an opportunity to learn. Don’t think only you have all the answers.